In an increasingly interconnected world, the speed of travel and the impact of congestion have become pivotal factors in assessing the efficiency and liveability of cities. A recent study conducted by economists at Aalto University in Finland sheds light on these aspects, examining traffic speed across more than 1,000 global cities. Surprisingly, the research reveals that the correlation between travel time and congestion is not straightforward.
Travel Time vs Congestion:
Contrary to expectations, travel time in a city is not solely determined by the level of traffic congestion on its roads. The study highlights that factors such as road quality, layout, and natural obstacles like rivers and hills play significant roles in determining travel speed. To understand this distinction, it is crucial to differentiate between travel speed, which remains unaffected by traffic, and congestion, which emerges as the result of the interplay between speed and traffic volume.
Impacting Factors:
The study, leveraging data from Google Maps, examined cities worldwide while excluding China and South Korea due to data limitations. The researchers created representative trips within each city, simulating commutes and typical journeys, and then collected data on millions of trips across different times and days in 2019. It was found that the wealth of the country in which a city is located is the primary predictor of travel time. The fastest cities predominantly exist in mid-sized municipalities in the United States, where wide and numerous highways facilitate speedy travel. Conversely, the slowest cities, such as Dhaka, Lagos, and Manila, are mostly located in developing countries where infrastructure struggles to keep pace with population growth.
The Complexity of Congestion:
While travel time tends to align with the wealth of the host country, congestion exhibits a more complex pattern. Highly congested cities span a range of wealthy, poor, and middle-income cities worldwide. While this category includes developing world urban centers such as Bogota and Mexico City, it also encompasses global cities like New York City and London, reflecting the impact of population size on congestion levels. Interestingly, some cities manage to attain fast travel speeds despite congestion. Notably, Nashville, Austin, Tampa, Houston, and Atlanta rank among the top 25% most congested cities globally while maintaining travel times within the top 10%.
Tailored Approaches to Improve Travel Time:
The study emphasizes the need for tailored approaches when addressing travel time challenges in different cities. What works effectively in one city may not yield similar results elsewhere. For instance, attempting to reduce traffic volume by implementing restrictions on vehicular movement and regulating business hours, as seen in Dhaka, may only yield marginal improvements. Policymakers must consider the specific circumstances of their cities and avoid relying solely on traffic studies commissioned for cities in different countries.
The Significance of Fast Travel:
While fast travel speed may seem desirable, it is important to recognize that it does not necessarily equate to an attractive or exemplary city. In some cases, it could signify excessive investments in infrastructure disproportionate to a city’s needs. As a thought-provoking example, Flint, Michigan, which boasts the fastest travel time, has witnessed a significant population decline over the decades.
The study’s findings shed light on the multifaceted nature of travel time and congestion in cities worldwide. Factors beyond traffic volume, such as road infrastructure and natural terrain, significantly impact travel speed. By recognizing the uniqueness of their situations, city planners can develop targeted strategies to improve travel times that align with their specific challenges and goals. Ultimately, creating efficient transportation systems goes beyond simply reducing congestion; it requires thoughtful consideration of a city’s individual circumstances.
Market Capital Research 